Accuracy of the Cell-Set Model on a Single Vane-Type Vortex Generator in Negligible Streamwise Pressure Gradient Flow with RANS and LES

Abstract

Passive flow control devices are included in the design of wind turbine blades in order to obtain better performance and reduce loads without consuming any external energy. Vortex Generators are one of the most popular flow control devices, whose main objective is to delay the flow separation and increase the maximum lift coefficient. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations of a Vortex Generator (VG) on a flat plate in negligible streamwise pressure gradient conditions with the fully-resolved mesh model and the cell-set model using Large Eddy Simulation (LES) and Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) were carried out, with the objective of evaluating the accuracy of the cell-set model taking the fully-resolved mesh model as benchmark. The implementation of the cell-set model entailed a considerable reduction of the number of cells, which entailed saving simulation time and resources. The coherent structures, vortex path, wall shear stress and size, strength and velocity profiles of the primary vortex have been analyzed. The results show good agreements between the fully-resolved mesh model and the cell-set mode with RANS in all the analyzed parameters. With LES, acceptable results were obtained in terms of coherent structures, vortex path and wall shear stress, but slight differences between models are visible in the size, strength and velocity profiles of the primary vortex. As this is considered the first application of the cell-set model on VGs, further research is proposed, since the implementation of the cell-set model can represent an advantage over the fully-resolved mesh model.